1. vidIQ
Best for: An all-round replacement with AI ideas and research
The vidIQ browser extension adds scorecards and research inside YouTube and YouTube Studio. The web app adds keyword research with demand and competition, competitor and outlier tracking, Daily Ideas, AI Coach, thumbnail generation, and MCP access for AI assistants such as ChatGPT and Claude.
Compared with TubeBuddy: vidIQ has no dedicated A/B testing tool (YouTube Studio's native test covers this), and it puts research and optimization ahead of catalog-wide bulk editing.
Pricing: Free plan with 150 AI credits a month, including MCP. Boost: $19 a month, or $199 billed yearly. Source: vidIQ plans.
vidIQ vs TubeBuddy